While I’m happy with how it holds flies, there’s still some work to do. Visually, I think the outside needs a different texture, so I have a different shell in the works. Functionally, I don’t like the big holes in the lid, so I think having a spool for a lid is bad. Also, I’m not a fan of having loose parts when I’m on the water, so I’m working on a leash/hinge for the lid.
Level line spools
The other project is a thinner version of the line spools. The original spools are a bit too tall if your only using level line.
Figure [6] Comparing thickness of one standard spool (left) to two thin spools (right)
It’s challenging to miniaturize an already compact design, and the results have been underwhelming. I’m thinking of ditching the mini spool approach. My next attempt at a level line spool will be a standard spool that’s modified to accept two lines. There’d be a divider in the middle of the arbor, and it would have the “top” geometry on the bottom too.
I’m still experimenting with these and would be happy to get some feedback/suggestions.
I’ve come around on the thin spool. I had to sit down with a friend a few times to really talk-out some ideas. I hadn’t quite understood what the thin spool was, and how to get there. It took a few more rounds of prototypes, but the design is finally working.
I love the thinner idea, the previous version was maybe a bit thick and on the heavy side. I’ll have to order some up and try them out. I assume they are compatible with the previous line winders?
Glad you like it. Yeah, the regular spool was definitely too big if you’re running level line.
Yes, the thin spools are still compatible with the regular spools. They’re in the same ecosystem as the other gadgets. If you do get some, let me know what you think.
I’m a big fan of the Oni spools; I must have at least 12 by now. If you look closely at them, they’re actually 3D printed too. I think they use SLS though, so it’s a little hard to tell.
When I set out to make the thin spools, I wanted something similar to the Oni spools in both size and function. However, that’s the extent of the similarities. I used different mechanisms to achieve, and hopefully improve on, the performance.
The fly box design is complete. I did rework the look, and I’m happy with where it’s at. The new version is also less slippery to hold onto. Check out the sequence of prototypes:
I’m also thinking of making a version of the box without the rubber fly-holder. Instead, it would have a few divided compartments, like a conventional tackle sorter. It might make a nice place to store other bits of tackle like micro split shot, or extra lillian. Anyone else think that might be useful?
The lid has also seen some changes. The lid is now a thin spool. These make a better lid because they have a solid bottom and they’re compact. The downside is that you cant store thick floating or furled lines on them. But fear not my thick line aficionados, Guenther has your back. The thin spool now doubles as a tippet dispenser. We developed a custom rubber band that you can put on or take off to make it work like an ordinary tippet dispenser. Here’s one of the prototypes loaded with 30m of 5x:
I’ve just launched a new version of the magnetic rod mount. This version uses zip ties that are rubber coated to create a firm non-slip connection. These work even better than the o-ring version when mounting to extra large rods, like those used for keiryu or salmon fishing. You can get them on my store here.
So were did this project come from? A little while back I saw this Tenkara line winder that uses rubberized zip ties. In their marketing they claim the zip ties are actually better than o-rings. I was a bit doubtful, but intrigued, so I set out to test it. After a bit of work I was able adapt my existing design to use zip ties. The result? It works about the same as o-rings.
The one case where the zip ties are better is on big rods. Anyone who’s tried to mount a fuji hook keeper on a keriuy rod knows that the standard sized o-rings just don’t cut it. Similarly, my magnetic rod mounts just never stayed attached to my bigger rods, something I always meant to fix. With the zip ties up and running, i can finally put a mount on my 9m keiryu rod. Yay!